Disputes are where escrow earns its keep. When an order goes wrong — wrong item, non-delivery, quality issues, vendor disappearance — the dispute process determines whether you get your money back. This guide covers when to dispute, what evidence matters, and how resolution typically works.
Open a dispute when:
Do not dispute over subjective dissatisfaction — "not what I expected" without evidence is a weak claim that vendors win. Disputes require provable problems.
Most issues resolve faster with direct vendor communication. Send a PGP-encrypted message describing the problem and giving the vendor a reasonable window (usually 3–7 days) to respond or reship. Many disputes never need escalation — vendors know unresolved disputes damage their rating.
Find the order in your market account — each order has its own dispute button. Don't finalize the order first; finalization releases escrow permanently.
Choose the category that matches your issue — non-delivery, wrong item, quality, etc. Be accurate; the reason affects how the dispute is evaluated.
This is where disputes are won or lost. Include tracking numbers, photos of what arrived (or didn't), PGP message logs, and a clear timeline. Vague disputes lose.
Market staff or automated systems review the evidence. Resolution times vary — days to weeks depending on complexity. Stay patient and respond to any staff questions promptly.
Possible outcomes: full refund to your market balance, partial refund, reshipment, or dispute denied. If denied and you have new evidence, you can appeal in some cases.
| Issue | Winning Evidence |
|---|---|
| Non-delivery | Tracking showing no movement for 2+ weeks, delivery confirmation to wrong address, vendor admitting non-ship |
| Wrong item | Photos of received product vs. listing photos, vendor's own description contradicting what arrived |
| Quality issues | Photos/video of product, lab results if applicable, comparison to listing claims |
| Vendor unresponsive | Screenshots of PGP messages sent and ignored, timestamps showing days without reply |
| Partial shipment | Order confirmation showing quantity ordered vs. what arrived, photos of received amount |
When a dispute resolves in your favor, the escrowed funds return to your market balance — not directly to your crypto wallet. From there you can withdraw to your personal wallet or use the balance for future orders. Withdrawals typically take 24–48 hours to process.