Home/Guides/Disputes

Vhagar Market Disputes & Refunds

Disputes are where escrow earns its keep. When an order goes wrong — wrong item, non-delivery, quality issues, vendor disappearance — the dispute process determines whether you get your money back. This guide covers when to dispute, what evidence matters, and how resolution typically works.

When to Open a Dispute

Open a dispute when:

Do not dispute over subjective dissatisfaction — "not what I expected" without evidence is a weak claim that vendors win. Disputes require provable problems.

Before You Dispute: Try the Vendor First

Most issues resolve faster with direct vendor communication. Send a PGP-encrypted message describing the problem and giving the vendor a reasonable window (usually 3–7 days) to respond or reship. Many disputes never need escalation — vendors know unresolved disputes damage their rating.

How to Open a Dispute

Go to the order page

Find the order in your market account — each order has its own dispute button. Don't finalize the order first; finalization releases escrow permanently.

Select the dispute reason

Choose the category that matches your issue — non-delivery, wrong item, quality, etc. Be accurate; the reason affects how the dispute is evaluated.

Provide detailed evidence

This is where disputes are won or lost. Include tracking numbers, photos of what arrived (or didn't), PGP message logs, and a clear timeline. Vague disputes lose.

Wait for resolution

Market staff or automated systems review the evidence. Resolution times vary — days to weeks depending on complexity. Stay patient and respond to any staff questions promptly.

Accept the outcome

Possible outcomes: full refund to your market balance, partial refund, reshipment, or dispute denied. If denied and you have new evidence, you can appeal in some cases.

What Evidence Wins Disputes

IssueWinning Evidence
Non-deliveryTracking showing no movement for 2+ weeks, delivery confirmation to wrong address, vendor admitting non-ship
Wrong itemPhotos of received product vs. listing photos, vendor's own description contradicting what arrived
Quality issuesPhotos/video of product, lab results if applicable, comparison to listing claims
Vendor unresponsiveScreenshots of PGP messages sent and ignored, timestamps showing days without reply
Partial shipmentOrder confirmation showing quantity ordered vs. what arrived, photos of received amount

Refund Mechanics

When a dispute resolves in your favor, the escrowed funds return to your market balance — not directly to your crypto wallet. From there you can withdraw to your personal wallet or use the balance for future orders. Withdrawals typically take 24–48 hours to process.

Market balance ≠ safe storageRefunded funds sitting in your market balance are exposed to market-level risks (exit scams, hacks). Withdraw promptly after winning a dispute.

Disputes You Can't Win

The golden ruleNever finalize an order until you've inspected the product and confirmed it matches the listing. Finalization is permanent — escrow releases, dispute window closes, recourse ends.

Next: Fees Explained →